{
  "paper_id": "review_20251127_210935",
  "novelty_dimensions_checked": [
    "gap_identification",
    "contribution_delta",
    "idea_provenance",
    "method_novelty",
    "question_novelty",
    "result_theory_novelty",
    "data_context_novelty"
  ],
  "contribution_claims": [
    {
      "claim_id": "C01",
      "claim_text": "First, it develops a model for assessing protection failure through convergent quantitative and qualitative evidence.",
      "linked_prior_work": [
        "Spagat et al. (2009)",
        "Seybolt et al. (2013)",
        "Creswell & Clark (2018)",
        "Fricker (2007)",
        "Boltanski (1999)",
        "Galtung (1969)",
        "Braun & Clarke (2006)"
      ],
      "scores": {
        "gap_identification": 1,
        "contribution_delta": 0,
        "idea_provenance": 1
      },
      "derivative_risk": "MEDIUM",
      "notes": "Gap implied but weakly linked; no measurable delta; moderate conceptual recombination."
    },
    {
      "claim_id": "C02",
      "claim_text": "Second, it specifies mechanisms of credibility construction in humanitarian documentation under duress.",
      "linked_prior_work": [
        "Fricker (2007)",
        "Boltanski (1999)",
        "Weidmann (2015)",
        "Restrepo et al. (2016)"
      ],
      "scores": {
        "gap_identification": 1,
        "contribution_delta": 0,
        "idea_provenance": 1
      },
      "derivative_risk": "MEDIUM",
      "notes": "Gap implied; no measurable improvement; adapts existing epistemic justice concepts."
    },
    {
      "claim_id": "C03",
      "claim_text": "Third, it provides empirical evidence of mortality patterns indicating systemic rather than incidental protection failures.",
      "linked_prior_work": [
        "Spagat et al. (2009)",
        "Seybolt et al. (2013)",
        "O’Driscoll (2020)",
        "Hirsch et al. (2015)"
      ],
      "scores": {
        "gap_identification": 1,
        "contribution_delta": 0,
        "idea_provenance": 1
      },
      "derivative_risk": "MEDIUM",
      "notes": "Applies known conflict epidemiology methods to Gaza context; no performance delta."
    }
  ],
  "sub_scores": {
    "method_novelty": 1.0,
    "question_novelty": 1.0,
    "result_theory_novelty": 1.0,
    "data_context_novelty": 2.0
  },
  "rkv_contribution_score": 5.0,
  "novelty_classification": "LOW",
  "novelty_flags": [
    "No measurable delta",
    "Gap not grounded in literature",
    "All novelty comes from recombination only"
  ],
  "metadata": {
    "model": "deepseek-chat",
    "paper_id": "review_20251127_210935",
    "max_contribution_claims": 10,
    "domain": "healthcare",
    "paper_title": "Humanitarian Collapse and Civilian Mortality in Gaza (2023–2025): A Mixed-Methods Analysis of Conflict Mortality Patterns"
  }
}